Appellate & Post-Conviction Relief

Attorneys at Mitchell | Stein | Carey | Chapman have argued before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the Arizona Supreme Court and the Arizona Court of Appeals. Kathy Brody and Karen Smith are also admitted to practice before the United States Supreme Court and have submitted briefs to the Court. The firm is based in Phoenix and handles appeals and post-conviction matters in Arizona state courts and in federal court.

The matters we handle include:

  • Direct appeals in state and federal court
  • Post-conviction relief proceedings
  • Federal habeas corpus, including capital habeas
  • Wrongful conviction and innocence matters
  • Clemency, including commutation and pardon, before the Arizona Board of Executive Clemency
  • Civil appeals
  • Amicus briefs in state and federal appellate courts

Our approach

Appeals and post-conviction matters begin with understanding what happened before the case reached us. In a direct appeal, that means reviewing the trial record, transcripts and filings, identifying issues that were raised or preserved, and determining whether there are grounds to challenge the conviction or sentence.

Post-conviction cases can require a different kind of review. They may involve evidence that was not presented at trial, witnesses who need to be located or interviewed, records that were not previously available, or changes in the law that affect the case. In those matters, the work can involve investigation as well as legal research and briefing.

Our attorneys bring experience from different parts of this process. Some handle both trials and appeals. Others have spent years working specifically on appellate, habeas and innocence matters, including work at the Arizona Justice Project and in a federal capital habeas unit.

Challenging a conviction after trial

We represent clients at different stages after a conviction, from direct appeals following sentencing to post-conviction proceedings brought years later. The issues are different in every case. Some involve an alleged error during the trial or sentencing. Others involve evidence that was not previously developed, questions about prior representation, or changes in the law after the conviction became final.

Our work includes direct appeals, state and federal post-conviction proceedings, federal habeas corpus, and petitions before the Arizona Board of Executive Clemency. Attorneys in this practice have represented clients in matters that resulted in new hearings, new sentences and release from custody after decades of incarceration.

Our attorneys

Kathy Brody handles criminal defense, constitutional rights, white collar defense, professional licensing discipline including lawyer ethics and bar defense, ABS, public records law, civil rights, and appellate and post-conviction matters.

Molly Brizgys represents clients in criminal defense, appellate and post-conviction litigation, including the Ninth Circuit, the Arizona Supreme Court and federal habeas, along with healthcare professional defense and student discipline and Title IX.

Karen Smith represents clients in criminal defense, government investigations before the DOJ, SEC and State Attorneys General, appellate and post-conviction matters, wrongful conviction and innocence work, False Claims Act defense, civil rights litigation, white collar criminal defense, federal habeas, and clemency, including commutation and pardon.

Dave Roscoe handles criminal defense, including domestic violence, theft and property crimes, fraud, homicide and violent crimes, as well as DUI and vehicular crimes, sex crimes, drug cases, computer and technology offenses, white collar crimes, juvenile crimes, and post-conviction and appellate litigation.

Flynn Carey represents clients in healthcare board discipline defense, peer review, student discipline and Title IX, felony and misdemeanor defense, administrative law, and family law litigation support.

Published decisions

  • Crespin v. Ryan, 46 F.4th 803 (9th Cir. 2022)
  • Crespin v. Ryan, 51 F.4th 819 (9th Cir. 2022)
  • Crespin v. Ryan, 56 F.4th 796 (9th Cir. 2023)
  • State v. Gordon in & for County of Mohave, 581 P.3d 215 (Ariz. 2025)
  • State v. Murray, 250 Ariz. 543, 482 P.3d 1038 (2021)
  • Matter of Cortez, 247 Ariz. 534, 453 P.3d 813 (Ct. App. 2019)
  • Lafler v. Cooper, 566 U.S. 156 (2012)
  • State v. Sorensen, 255 Ariz. 316, 531 P.3d 378 (Ct. App. 2023)
  • Bridgeman v. Certa, 251 Ariz. 471, 493 P.3d 898 (Ct. App. 2021)
  • State v. Stapley, 227 Ariz. 61, 251 P.3d 1048 (Ct. App. 2011)

Representative outcomes

  • Helped Barry Jones in Arizona and Ha’im Sharif in Nevada regain their freedom after each served 29 years on death row as a result of being wrongfully convicted
  • Won parole for a client incarcerated for 25 years at their first hearing before the Arizona Board of Executive Clemency
  • Obtained a new sentencing hearing in federal habeas corpus for a client serving a life sentence
  • Argued and won published decisions on questions of criminal law in the Ninth Circuit, the Arizona Supreme Court and the Arizona Court of Appeals
  • Handled appeals from the lower court decisions before the Maricopa County Superior Court and the Arizona Court of Appeals
  • Authored briefs in the Arizona Supreme Court, the Ninth Circuit and the United States Supreme Court
  • Received favorable clemency recommendation for client serving a flat-time sentence
  • Represented multiple clients in successful parole and absolute discharge hearings
  • Successfully represented multiple individuals in post-conviction proceedings challenging whether their life sentences include parole eligibility
  • Successfully represented a client at a 603(L) hearing

If you are considering an appeal, seeking post-conviction relief or need help understanding your options after a conviction, call (602) 358-0290 or contact us online.

Meet the attorneys fighting for you

Our attorneys have successfully defended clients in federal, state, and local courts. And we’re ready to work for you.

View attorneys